If you have the 2 game rental plan, have both games out, you conquered both games. Just take off the front cover of the envelope the games came in, stick each individual game into its right case, then seal and ship prepaid envelope! No stamp needed! Also you can keep any game as long as you want! Just make the monthly payments, you should be fine! Make sure to put the games that have either available NOW, HIGH, or MEDIUM as your top 5 games on your GameQ. Anything below that you will not receive that specific game for a while. I hoped this helped!