Best Answer
it ships to people who have had it in their Q longer. I've watched games pass me by multiple times when I look on the site one day seeing "Available Now" next to a game, then the next day says "Low" - you should have had it in your Q for much longer than 2 weeks, there's tons of people who put it in their Q months ago, I guarantee it.
I've been a subscriber to gamefly for a year now, and it took me a while to finally figure that one out. Keep it up there, but play some other games during the mean time until your copy will be sent.