Red Dead Redemption. GTA4 is by all means a fantastic title, as Assassin's Creed, though Red Ded Redemption is an overall greater experience in every perspective. It has a vast, open, detailed, living world set in western America, While Assassin's Creed's world feels rather scripted and bland after only an hour or so in. GTA has the same feel as Red Ded Redemption, though much less intense. The world feels like a giant comedy, the driving controls are almost too loose, and the story just isn't as gripping. RDR has a great single player, multiplayer, visuals, replay value, and DLC. The other two choices just don't hit that level of greatness, not to say they are bad titles, but simply not as good.