i think all those who complain are either newbies who want something instantly,don't understand how gamefly works,or have only new games in their queues so as gamefly already has them to other people. i've had no problems with shipping times being 2-4 days. a lot of the complaints are like i shipped it yesterday when will i get my next or why don't they ship
i would rent it first because i bought it and love it but with any new game it always has some hate but this one seems to have mroe then the deserved and maybe that's just because so many people bought it just to wait until crysis 2 but i'm not sure.
i liked it. it only takes a few hours but I like that because it has the 61 newspapers and needs to be replayed for some of the achievements unless your extremely beast and evne then I don't think it would be physically possible based on every level has achievements for 1. completeing 2. completeing on hardest difficulty 3, completeing without dieing/reloading checkpoint and 4. individual level achievements 2 per level as far as I can tell.
i don't know about you but a game a week is average as long as you send your game back and assuming your only paying for one game membership. even so I calculated that for myself considering you save travel time to a rental store and the price of a rental for only 7 days max i only need to get two in one month to make it cheaper then renting for a rental store and that is why such stores are colapsing.