I would have probably given this game a solid 8 or so, but the game constantly freezes each time I play. I have to shut down my xbox to get it to work. Release a patch to get the bugs out and this would be a really solid game.
I use to play the WWF/E games a lot when I was younger, and hearing all the praise this game got, I wanted to give it a shot. I was pretty disappointed on a few fronts.
1) Graphically better than it's predecessors it still looked dated by todays standards.
2) Creative Mode is nearly the exact same one I remember from the last game I played. Right down to the tattoos you could put on your characters.
3) I loved the fact you could play through the glory that was the Attitude Era. But it sucks you can't experience it for yourself using a created superstar.
4) Controls are still bad, and in my opinion have been since the Smackdown games started.
Overall it's a disappointment to me. I was hoping for something really new, and they changed a few things, polished it up here and there, but this is the same game I've played before, and in some cases it was better back then.