This game is the first wrestling game that is made to be a wrestling game. There is focus on the story lines just as much as it focuses on the in game action.
There are a plethora of unlock able characters and extras and the Road to Wrestlemania is long and involved with common actions that you'd find in any real WWE storyline.
The intros are great the modeling and action look realistic but aren't afraid to get a tiny bit over the top.
The bad: The game can be buggy, which is common on a game with this much in it. The characters will sometimes hit nothing, wrestlers will magically float after being thrown to the turnbuckle. Not terrible but after a few hours you'll see what I am talking about.
The actions can be repetitive having to do certain actions over and over to get a needed action. I do wish there were more moves for each character but that is a VERY small complaint.
I had trouble with certain wrestlers that are WAY more difficult that any other and there is little you can do but try for a reversal, over and over. They just seem to have an unnatural ability to chain moves together without pause or limit. This can make it extremely frustrating and make me want to stop playing all together against some opponents. You eventually find some cheap and un-fun way to beat them but its after WAY too many times of trying.
Voice acting was very good except Kevin Nash who seemed to be muted on everything he did.
Other than that, its a fantastic game full of old and new wrestlers and this game has a ton of depth. I am not a wrestling fan (well since I was 10) but I enjoyed this game tremendously and feel this is the best wrestling game I have ever played, narrowly beating WCW vs NWO on N64.