Overall I did not think Top Spin 3 is a bad game. It is difficult to get used to the controls for a beginner but after 4 or 5 matches a beginner can get the hang of it. The two areas that I think the game is weak in is on-line play and the amount of computer competitors. It would be nice to be able to play against other players on-line. Also the amount of computer players is just too few. You seem to play the same players over and over again. This is the type of game that when you first play it you think it is fun and a pretty good challenge. As you play it more, it starts to become boring and repetitive. Then you put the game away and when you come back to it at a later time it has it's fun back. Basically I think this is a good rental but if you purchase the game I think it may spend more time in the box then in the Wii gaming system.
I only played it for 15 minutes before i decided to send it back. The controls are awful on the wii. I don't think my girlfriend played it for 5 minutes before she gave up on it. I would like to try the xbox 360 version of the game sometime. To review the game itself