If you rented this game expecting something like the previous two paper mario titles then you will be sadly mistaken. Don't get me wrong super paper mario is a fun game but it lacks the role playing elements of the other paper mario titles. This game is also very short I beat it in 20 hours.
I wasn't expecting much after playing the Original Mario Paper on Gamecube.
I was totally drawn into this game. The flipping of the playing field adds a totally new dimension to the game. If you enjoy looking around every nook and cranny for stuff, this is the game for you because not only do you have one field to look for stuff, you have an additional field when you flip your view. It's GREAT.