I'm giving this a 5, because I'm sure these games were awesome when they first came out and were still relevant. Unless you're a giant fan of Silent Hill and nostalgia in general, I would avoid this one. I put it in and played for no more than 10 minutes before getting tired of the archaic control setup and the slow pace of the games. I think if you want to play something in the same genre, I'd recommend Alan Wake or maybe Silent Hill: Homecoming. But, I just couldn't get into this one. Sorry, Silent Hill.