Sherlock Holmes: Mystery of the Mummy for Nintendo DS Reviews by Gamers

Let me begin by saying that I think this game is great example of why GameFly is so amazing. I had glanced at this game a couple times but felt it was definitely a rental and after plying it confirmed this hypothesis.

The gameplay is average. You move around the game either using the stylus or the directional pad (DP is much easier than stylus) searching for clues or parts of puzzles. Most mystery games like this that I have played clues are typically highlighted or offset slightly. In this game it was easy to miss clues even when scanning slowly and carefully.
Overall: Pretty average as mystery games go.

The voice acting sounds like amateur work. Sherlock has a high obnoxious voice that would better suit a cackling villian. The rest of the cast perform their lines as if doing a first read through, lacking emotion. Overall: mediocre is too kind.

The puzzles in the game are actually pretty good though challenging with all the running around; at the end of the day rather enjoyable to solve. There were few puzzles I had trouble with, though adding a little more explanation to them would be nice.
Overall: Good.

The visual look of the game is good. Everything looks very Victorian, though you only really roam the one house. A couple parts ended up looking a little faded, though you can adjust the brightness and such in the game.
Overall: Great

All things considered the game is a quick play and best with the volume on mute while listening to some classical music. Apparently it is a port of a PC game but the sound needed more remixing for the small DS speakers. The replay value of this is low which is why it makes a great rental.
Overall : C-, rent it.

I love mystery games. Unfortunately, this game left me a little disappointed. The resolution is fuzzy. Moving across the screen is hard to control. The game gives you clues for every single step of the game. So you will need lots of will power not to look at the clues. The story line is OK, but not something to keep you on the edge of your seat. If you are just looking for a time killer, go ahead and rent. However, I strongly discourage buying.