Rent Red Steel for Wii
view large frontback

Red Steel

Rent

Start your 1-month FREE Trial!

GF Rating
5.6

3403 ratings

Critic & User Reviews

GF Rating
2

Really Bad

RED STEEL isn't worth a RED NICKEL!!

posted by Demanacus (DENVER, CO) Dec 8, 2006

Member since Jul 2006

Graphically On-Par w/ Early PS2/Original XBox Titles (HALO-1). Awkward & Clunky Controls. Enemy AI seems DENSE & SLOW; Feels like you're fighting against FORREST GUMP. Cliche Racial Stereotyping. Swordfighting is AWFUL.
==Effort/Creativity: B+ ==Execution/Delivery: D-

I've gamed on almost every home console since Intelivision, Collecovision, Atari2600, etc. Yes, I am a 30 Year Old Hardcore Gamer. I've played some pretty bad games through the years, and this one is somewhere near the bottom. Granted, I've played worse, but this one IS pretty bad.

First off, I think part of the problem is how much this game was hyped, between the E3, Tokyo Game Show, etc. I was, as many of you were, led to believe that RED STEEL would be the -PREMIER- Launch Title for the Nintendo Wii. I recall seeing video clips of intuitive Sword Fighting with the Wii-mote, and precision shooting with the pointer. I also recall seeing graphics that looked at least a LITTLE better than this, even though it WAS still in the developmental stages. Now I look at this game, and see inferior graphics (inferior to, for example, BLACK for the original Xbox; or perhaps similar to the original HALF-LIFE that was ported to the PS2).

Now, for the controls: Have you ever played Warcraft, Age of Empires, or maybe Command & Conqure? Moving the camera is very similar to these classic titles: bounce the pointer off the edge of the screen to slide it around. VERY awkward this time around. After 5-6 hours of gameplay, I was -STILL- unable to just "point & click" to shoot. I found myself all too often going from looking at the SKY, to the GROUND, back to the SKY, and then somewhere WAY off to the side while trying to "turn" to take a shot. The Swordfighting was a selling point for me at E3/TGS, but now I found the swordplay to be inaccurate, unresponsive at times, and generally annoying.

Enemy AI seems FORREST GUMP'ish; standing still, WAITING to be shot at.

All in all, V-E-R-Y disappointing.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse

GF Rating
8

Very Good

Not a bad choice

posted by nintendo10 (BLOOMINGTON, IN) Dec 2, 2006

Member since Jul 2006

Wow! This game can be pretty intense at times. I have trouble laying down the controller at times. Red Steel really takes advantage of the Wii controllers. Sometimes the game itself can be frustrating due to the difficulty to control your player. It doesnt seem like the reaction time is quite up to par. Although it does have some problems and is difficult at times, this shouldnt make anyone not want to own it if they are looking for a great FPS out right now!

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse

GF Rating
9

Excellent

Awesome!!!!!

posted by Soniccloud (SOMERSET, KY) Dec 1, 2006

Member since Aug 2006

Really I could not wait for Red steel to be available to rent so I just bought it! And it is awesome! It takes awhile to get used to, but its still is a buy. I now this is short, but I wanted to give you time to run to the store and pick it up, sooooooooooooo...... Go!

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse