Poor Score Undeserved, AGAIN!
posted by wdwyer (LAKE ARIEL, PA) Apr 24, 2008
Member since Apr 2007
7
out of
8
gamers (88%) found this review helpful
Something has got to give. Once again, a game falls to the absolute extremes of unbalanced ratings here at Gamefly. I see all too often here, good games that get bad ratings, and I have the perfect example. NIGHTS: Journey of Dreams is a good game, the best? No. But far from the current 5.1 rating users here seem to think it.
I have noticed a trend here at Gamefly. Two games can be so much alike, yet if one has a popular character, the ratings are better. Case in point. NIGHTS and SUPER MARIO GALAXY. Go on look for yourself. Both games generally have the same gameplay & controls. Pretty much the same objectives. Graphics do not standout on either title. Yet one is called "the first must buy game of the Wii." And the other is called "clumbsy and the difficulty of the missions are unbalanced".
There are 2 differences between these games. TWO. SMG is generally a free roaming game (Which means, outside of flying, you can go anywhere you want within the boundary of the game). NIGHTS has a set course by which you can freely roam (Which means your free to fly about the screen in any direction, but you can't deviate from a set path around the world).
The other is obvious. As a character, Mario is SO much more popular than NIGHTS. That is undisputable.
Yet if both games generally play the same way. Why is NIGHTS sitting at a current 5.1 and Mario at a current 8.8?
It's a popular vote...nothing more.
I picked each game up, and played through them. I could immediately see how to use the controls, as well as, whatever resemblance of a rehashed story each has. It's not rocket science.
They both have their flaws, and both have their strengths. NIGHTS is undeserving of the low rating. It's not a 10, yet neither is SMG. You start to wonder if these people who are giving these low ratings actually play the games through. How can you trust a review based on 5 minutes or a day of gameplay? Trust a reviewer who PLAYS through a game. NIGHTS is not a bad game.
Was this review helpful?
Report
Abuse