Rent Need for Speed: Carbon for Wii
view large frontback

Need for Speed: Carbon

Not Rentable
Also on:Xbox, Xbox 360, GC, PS2, PS3
GF Rating
6.5

1134 ratings

Critic & User Reviews

GF Rating
4

Weak

Waste of time

posted by FastDaddy (REDMOND, WA) Dec 6, 2006

Member since Nov 2006

4 out of 10 gamers (40%) found this review helpful

Boy was I excited at the prospect of a new NFS title, and boy am I dissapointed. I am a car nut from way back and NFS Underground 2 is my all time favorite racing game. Why? The physics and reactions to tuning are very close to the real world, and I get to do what I bought the game to do...RACE!

Then came NFS Most Wanted and while the concept is good, outrunning the cops gets old VERY fast. This was a big move away from just letting me race.

Now, here comes Carbon. I saw some trailers and did some reading and thought "YES, another great NFS racing game!". Imagine my dissapointment when I fired up my new copy of Carbon in my new Wii and had to sit through a stupid movie to build a story line that is pointless. And no, there is no way, at least with the Wii version, to skip all this junk.

So, an hour later I'm through watching their lame stories, through enduring pointless "trial" runs (should be able to skip all of these if we wish) and am ready to race. I run and win my first race, and other than better graphics and a different city it felt exactly like NFS U2. But, instead of roaming around and unlocking shops to find performance parts I just jump back to the safe house and buy whatever it is I unlocked by winning the race. OK, dull but OK.

Second race. Half way through the cops get after me. I win the race, but have to continue avoiding the cops until I lose them. Second race of the game and I've got 17 police cars chasing me. I eluded them and shut the game off.

So, Electronic Arts worked long and hard on this concept. Take NFS U2, change the city and add a ton of lame movies, incorporate all the police from NFS MW and sell it as the latest and greatest. What a rip off. Get rid of the cops and let me race. I'd much rather have an upgrade to NFS U2 that adds more races. That game was fun and you spent all your time racing. Eluding cops is fun for about five minutes, then it gets old and annoying. Rent NFS U2. Much more fun!

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse

GF Rating
10

Perfect

better than midnight club

posted by nyancat5000 (LAS VEGAS, NV) Sep 2, 2011

Member since Aug 2011

this game is da bomb,its better than midnight club and it is better then test drive unlimited, U NEED DIS GAME IT PWNS AND OWNS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse

GF Rating
7

Good

What Midnight Club ought to be.

posted by hekifier (WINCHESTER, OH) May 4, 2011

Member since Apr 2011

The concept of taking to the midnight streets to race is an engaging one, but Midnight club consistently ruins it by making races like logic puzzles, where you need to sort a hundred different routes to find that one that works. But Need for Speed Carbon is more traditional, and it's a winner for that.

There's plenty of sexy woman in the game (Nikki!), but you'll need to adjust your focus to come on top in the sprints, checkpoint races, and other race types. There's also boss races, where you'll face a rival who will spam shortcuts, then you'll need to go to the canyons in a duel. You're supposed to follow the opposing driver as closely as possible, avoiding crashing or falling off, then re-do it this time in front and trying not to allow the enemy to score more points. The controls don't always offer the precision you need, but it's a nice change.

There are various control options, but the only few worth using is the wheel, which for some reason you'll need to turn the remote up to navigate menus, and another where you hold the remote forward to accelerate and turn the joystick on the nun-chuck.

The drifting mechanics can occasionally lock on you, causing you to crash and lose many races. It seems the racing engine needed more fine tuning, because this problem can even stop the game from being fun. At least you have a lengthy single player mode, quick races, free roam and cop chases though. The graphics are also really detailed and overflowing with style, suffering from less technical quirks than Undercover.

Like many Black Box efforts, here's another flawed but fun NFS on the Wii. It's exactly what I was hoping Midnight Club would be, but isn't. It's not a terrific game, there are some issues that I couldn't let slide, but it's still fun in it's own right if you're a fan of the series, or just want some solid racing action.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse