Rent NCAA Football 12 for Xbox 360
view large frontback

NCAA Football 12


Start your 1-month FREE Trial!

Also on:PS3
GF Rating

4050 ratings

Critic & User Reviews

GF Rating


NCAA Football 12 Review

posted by Zig997 (SIOUX FALLS, SD) Jul 12, 2011

Member since Feb 2011

9 out of 13 gamers (69%) found this review helpful

I bought this game brand new for 62 dollars, right away i could see all the graphical enhancements and the ESPN presentation was top notch, the 3D grass gave it a visual flourish, and all the additions they did to Road To Glory mode and you now being able to coach your team in Online Dynasty, I love the new tackling engine cause i am not feeling warped into a tackle. All in all this game is a definitely buy and it is worth the 62 bucks.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse

GF Rating

Very Good

How is made by the same people who make madden??

posted by reebok4523 (MAPLE SHADE, NJ) Nov 8, 2011

Member since Oct 2011

2 out of 3 gamers (67%) found this review helpful

In my short time with this game I can already tell how gOod it's gonnna be. The core gameplay and presentation is amazing. I don't understand how this game could come out a month earlier then madden and be a better polished game. When madden was being described this is what I thought it was gonna be like. For some reason the same company can make 2 similar games that share core fundinmentals but be completely dIfferent. There are so many features in this game my head was spinning. I Didn't know where to begin. Dynasty mode is amazing you have so much control. In the end all I want to see is madden being as good as NCAA. EA make both of them so it's unexeptable that they are so different.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse

GF Rating


New Game, same old problems.

posted by MDiver82 (PALM COAST, FL) Jul 14, 2011

Member since Dec 2006

6 out of 10 gamers (60%) found this review helpful

There isn't much change from '11 to '12; except for the revamped Road to Glory and the Coaching Carousel. Being able to alter conferences and BCS Bowl game tie-ins are cool too.

The problem is, a lot of the new features don't work quite yet, and we will need another patch soon.

Custom playbooks don't work, it's the chief complaint on the EA boards. There are other issues in Offline Dynasty; for instance the Televised games not registering so your Nationally Televised grade goes down every year, and sometimes it won't let you advance past week 15 (essentially killing the dynasty). Some other bugs persist, like using Supersim at your own risk; it can cause the system to freeze (It's used quite a bit as a Coordinator).

EA servers have been having problems, and it literally feels like I get booted from the server every 3 minutes. That's been a minor issue as well.

Ironman is cool for RTG; but you may just want to play DE or DT on defense, because the other team will never throw your direction and they get rid of the ball too fast when you are sent on blitzes. Also the recruiting process for it is a lot more involved. I like that change quite a bit. You pick 3 teams you want to go to. Then after every week you get additional offers from other schools that you can add to your interest list, and then you have to meet the scholarship requirement to sign with them. Requirement isn't that tough; unless you play as a DB.

All in all, it's another NCAA football game with another facelift, without much really adding to the actual gameplay. Coaching Carousel Is a much needed addition to Dynasty, but it doesn't add much to keeping Dynasty fresh.

It's a 7 now because of the game crashing bugs; and the bugs that devalue staple game modes like Dynasty.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse