I own 3 different versions of this game, (Xbox, PSP and 360). Having said that, I thought the graphics (with the exception of the eyes in the close ups) are really pretty good. I felt that the graphics were substantially better than the Xbox version.
That's about it as far as the good stuff.
I was crushed by the lack of Superstar mode. Also, specifically on defense, if you have a really good DE or linebacker, you can't really use them to any real benefit because you pretty much end up controlling the defense as whole as opposed to picking one player to "be". I can get used to the menu's. But why, in Gods name, did they completely change the controls of the game from the standard Xbox controls? The controllers aren't *that* much different.
Also the camera is wacked. Its either too close, or too far away.
This was the first game I purchased for my Xbox 360 and I am very disappointed in that purchase.