Was really looking forward to this one...
posted by GFR013 (MERRIFIELD, VA) Jan 17, 2009
Member since Jul 2004
7
out of
10
gamers (70%) found this review helpful
maybe a little too much since my expectations seem to have exceeded reality. That's not to say it's a bad game, but there are enough minor issues and quirks with it that keep it from being all it can be in my opinion. Several people have compared this to the Star Wars: Battlefront series, and rightly so, the games I kept thinking about though were the previous EA LotR ventures. Maybe that's the source of some of the issues I'm having with it. Instead of playing one of the main characters you play generic grunts for the most part (towards the end of any particular level you get to play one of the heroes to finish things off). In the context of the game they were going for it makes sense, but come on this is LotR, we want to play the heroes ;) They also screwed around a bit with the order and sequence of events. Maybe that's a little too nit-picky, but it still bugged me how they tried to wedge some of things in (the Moria level for example), and I'm not even that huge of a LotR fan.
Regarding the game itself, I thought the graphics and sound were great. The only problem I had was it was easy to get lost in the crowd since there is no indicator that points out your character and everyone of the same class looks the same. The levels are on the short side and there's not many of them so I think they are counting on the online part to keep people hook. Unfortunately this is another complaint I have. You have to register with their server in order to play online. As far as I know this goes for all multiplayer, so you can't even do a friend to friend play without logging in to their machines. Just one more hassle in my humble opinion.
Bottom line, it is a fun game in the same sense of the SW Battlefront series, a good button masher to blow some time with. Frankly I enjoyed the previous LotR button masher games a little more. I do strongly recommend it for a rental to try it out. Personally I'm going to wait until it hits the bargain table to buy it.
Was this review helpful?
Report
Abuse