Rent ICO and Shadow of the Colossus Collection for PS3
view large frontback

ICO and Shadow of the Colossus Collection

Rent

Start your 1-month FREE Trial!

GF Rating
7.6

2881 ratings

Critic & User Reviews

GF Rating
5

Fair

Honestly not sure

posted by SlajeD (WESTFIELD, IN) May 28, 2014

Member since Sep 2010

Part of me really wants to like these games and yet the flaws make it so hard to really like them. These two games get lots of hype but I think that sets them up for disappointing results. I was hoping the remake would maybe fix any off-putting flaws but I don't think they changed anything except graphics.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse

GF Rating
1

Horrible

I don't see why these games are so loved

posted by MizoOfOz (SHERMAN OAKS, CA) Jan 31, 2014

Member since Apr 2009

I missed getting to play these two titles when they were originally on the PS2, and all I ever heard was how great they are. And visually, yes, they are awesome looking games. However, everything else about them is horrible. Bad controls. Horrific camera. And as for the story, most of the time, I had no idea what was going on.

I'll start with Ico. You play some kid with horns that gets locked in some castle. Why? No idea. The game doesn't explain. It was later explained to me by a friend that it's because he has horns... Um, okay. I guess that makes sense. Anyways, you try to leave and run into a girl that is prisoner in the castle. Why? No idea. She doesn't have horns. The game has no real dialogue to explain these things. The object of the game is to escape with the girl. Simple, yes, but a tried and true gameplay idea. The problem is the girl is so incompetent that she can't even walk without you holding her hand. And if you leave her for more than a few seconds to solve some puzzle, shadow monsters come out and drag her away while she just screams for help, offering no resistance at all. After an hour of this, I gave up on the game and moved onto...

Shadow of the Colossus. Once again, I had no idea what was going on. Some girl was dead? Asleep? And you go off and kill giants because of it. Thankfully, this time I didn't have to escort someone that was dumber than dirt. Instead, I had to deal with a hugely annoying camera and controls that made it very difficult to play. I gave up around the fifth giant monster.

Like I said, I have no idea why these games are so loved by so many people. They're some of the worst I have ever played, and I've played a lot of bad games. And everyone keeps waiting for the developers next game, The Last Guardian, which has been delayed many times. Based on these two games, I hope it never comes out.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse

GF Rating
7

Good

Nothing's changed

posted by outsider161 (MUNDELEIN, IL) Jan 11, 2014

Member since Jan 2014

It's a remake of fun games from PS2. Nothing has been improved upon, including the graphics. These games are just as good as they were on the PS2 (nothing more) and that's just fine.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse