Critic & User Reviews
A new Harvest Moon.
posted by CoreyKei (OAK CREEK, WI) Sep 10, 2010
Member since Dec 2009
11 out of 12 gamers (92%) found this review helpful
They're cute. Everyone is kind of big headed and tiny bodied. The girls in this game look really nice. The boys, well they all look pretty "Blah" some of them are okay but some look like children. The animals look adorable! And you can get all kinds, from Dogs, cats, chickens, sheep, cows, and Horse.
It's kind of boring. It's always the same and okay but not as good as the other Harvest Moons.
The whole "Rock" of the game is the Bazaar. In the Bazaar you bring your produce and crops and whatever else you want and you sell it to the random people that are walking around. Sometimes a person will pay double depending on what you say. Your goal is to make a certain amount of money for each bazaar which happens each week. It's all so much fun.
Your job is to get the Bazaar to become the best bazaar in the entire world.
And get married and have a child.
-Some of the Boys and Girls look like they're 12.
-Time goes by really slow. (1min In Game = 1sec Real Life)
-There is no mining.
-People say the same thing day in and day out.
-You CANT sell your animals after you buy them.
Awesome New HM Installment!
posted by DebLee (ALBERTSON, NY) Aug 31, 2010
Member since Jul 2006
13 out of 15 gamers (87%) found this review helpful
- The graphics are beautiful for a DS game!
- You start with a KITCHEN! You do have to buy your own cookware, but at least you get a kitchen from the start of the game.
- You start with a BARN! And there's a pre-made outdoor pen for chickens with a REAL fence that you don't have to maintain, as well as a large grassy field for your livestock to feed on. It's all free when you start the game!
- The Shipping Bin is gone. Instead, you sell your wares at a weekly Bazaar. There's a shop in town where you can also sell things, but you won't make as much of a profit at that store. Also, there are many special items (animals, tools, ores) that can ONLY be bought at the Bazaar, so be sure to budget enough time to do some shopping too!
- Pets are actually USEFUL! You can train your dogs to herd livestock, and your cats can carry chickens out to the pen. And you can PLAY with your pets, using a dog bone and a cat bell!
- No more paying thousands of coins for Makers. Instead, there are three Windmills that unlock throughout Year 1, and you can make all your cheeses, wool, fertilizer, etc. for free!
- New crops, new trees, new tools, new items to make and sell! There's also new Festivals, such as the Wine Festival!
- Favorite characters from previous HM games, such as Chen, Gannon and Pierre make cameos!
- You can buy premade dishes from the Cafe, and automatically learn the recipe! And since you don't automatically eat the food, you can save it, gift it, or sell it at the Bazaar.
- The day is slightly slower since the time is counted by minutes. HOWEVER, time does NOT pause when you enter a house!
- Every night you can automatically save your game.
- HORSE RACES ARE BACK!!!
If you were curious about this game, I'd HIGHLY recommend it! After all, it's just a rental right?
Weakest Game in the Harvest Moon Series
posted by edesiree (MISSION VIEJO, CA) Sep 3, 2010
Member since Sep 2010
6 out of 8 gamers (75%) found this review helpful
1. The time is very slow, one minute in real time is one hour in the game. So when you finish all of your watering, caring for the animals and gathering miscellaneous (and limited) items from around the map it would be around 12 P.M. I would have no idea what to do with this spare time. Often I would sit around until 5 P.M. hit so I could put in the animals then go to sleep.
2. The world is very small in comparison to previous games, there's only six areas.
3. Money is not easy to come by early on in the game and most products in the game cost several thousand gold. Also, many products and items aren't worth very much.
4. New Freshness Rating. Although it was clever and kind of cool at first, the rating depending on the level of freshness affects the selling price. Super Fresh gets the most money and rotten you're better off tossing. I found that this heavily relates to timing because you can only sell once a week and I would often find that most of my products would end up fairly fresh by the time I could sell them.
5. Romancing bachelor/bachelorette. Not only do you have romance the man/woman you desire to be with but before you can marry them you must also reach five hearts with a specific person (each person has a different requirement).
6. No mining. Perhaps not all people like mining, but that is one of my favorite chores because it brings in good money, always available, and easy to get items in bulk.
7. No story whatsoever, the only goal in the game is to get the bazaar to become well-known again.
1. Bazaar system was fluid and enjoyable, albeit only once a week.
2. The graphics were beautiful.
3. You had all the upgrades at the start of the game.
4. Pets are useful so you can herd all your animals.
5. Fences never rot or need to fixed.
6. New festival and horses races are back.
7. Unlockable windmills instead of buying expensive makers.
It's good so far!
posted by Kystanir (FREEPORT, IL) Aug 29, 2010
Member since Aug 2010
3 out of 6 gamers (50%) found this review helpful
Worst HM Ever.
posted by Xzalor (PENSACOLA, FL) Apr 23, 2011
Member since Jul 2010
1 out of 2 gamers (50%) found this review helpful
Mixed-reactions to Grand Bazaar; Harvest Moon lite
posted by Markers (ONTARIO, CA) Aug 25, 2010
Member since Jul 2010
5 out of 12 gamers (42%) found this review helpful
Grand Bazaar follows the usual HM premise of you taking control of an abandoned farm, bringing it up to speed, and wooing the ladies/guys (the main character can be male/female). The twist is that you must help kickstart the local town's bazaar on weekends by selling various items found and grown by you. The is what I was looking forward to doing, simply because it had never been done before.
The bazaar-selling portion of the game is the game's strongpoint and the primary motivation to trudge on through the monotonous grind of farming life. I'm fairly used to this addictive grind, so it posed no problem to me. So farming, selling, and owning a shop; what could be wrong? Unfortunately, a lot.
For one, time passes by incredibly slow at a rate of 1 real second to 1 in-game second. This means each hour in the game is one minute. At first, I thought it was nice to have so much time to spare, but then it became a nightmare when I was finished watering my crops, collecting items, and talking to people by 11am; I frequently went to sleep at noon for this reason.
Oh, and another thing: the town is literally 6 transitions on the map. In other words, it's possibly the smallest world in the HM series. There is no mining (a major component of past iterations), beach, and so many common HM continuities.
Despite what I just mentioned, GB does has its moments. The bazaar system is really nice, the graphics are fantastic for a DS installment, and so on. I wish I could say more positive things about it, but I can't find anything else worth mentioning.
I would not recommend GB. Try Rune Factory: Frontier (Wii) or Harvest Moon DS.
Thank you for reading.
Same addictive monotony.
posted by tiloho (IRON RIVER, MI) Sep 28, 2010
Member since Jun 2005
1 out of 3 gamers (33%) found this review helpful
Fair game.. if you can find it..
posted by greg137 (CALDWELL, ID) Aug 2, 2012
Member since May 2010
Which is fine and all but the rarity of this game currently problematic.. It also has some issues with regards to the fact that you don't get a shipping bin, because of the fact that you need to use the bazaar to do the most of your selling.. Fair game overall though.. Try before you buy!
BORING BORING BORING!!!!!!!!!!!!
posted by harry4982 (AUBURN, WA) Oct 26, 2011
Member since Oct 2011
posted by gamefan06 (LITTLETON, CO) Jan 28, 2011
Member since Apr 2005
But not this time. I'm not going to go into huge amounts of detail about the game's mechanics, since if you're reading this you probably already know about it. But you see, outside of tending your farm, there is virtually NOTHING to do. Character's have absolutely zero personality and only say the same two or three things over and over, mining has been taken away, fishing is kind of useless since fish don't really sell for anything (Not to mention you have limited storage, so you don't really want to stock up on lower-selling items)...there just isn't any life to be found within the game's world.
Which is a shame, because the new Bazaar mechanic is actually really good. It's a clever new twist on the formula that forces you to think about how to properly grow your crops, and it suddenly makes cooking and item crafting much more important then ever before due to the high selling prices of your creations. But the problem is that there's just nothing else to look forward to. Even the busiest farmers will be done with their work by 10:00am, and all that's really left to do is forage for more stuff to sell. There's just no incentive to keep playing without all the extra activities and rewards Harvest Moon usually offers.
Harvest Moon Grand Bazaar isn't the worst game in the series, but it's definitely the most boring. It has its moments, and it may still be worth a rental for the die-hard fans out there. Just don't go expecting a new Friends of Mineral Town or anything.
A good addition to the series, but bland overall
posted by Sniezka2 (TOLEDO, OH) Jan 9, 2011
Member since Sep 2010
The game is easy to jump into, you start off with a lot of upgrades, and get more of them later on for free. No longer must you spend an entire year's earnings on stupid "makers" that only work for one or two items, and no longer must you spend endless months harvesting wood and stone to get a kitchen or a bath.
The only upgrades you must pay for are extra fields, and expansions of your stable and storage.
The new selling system is interesting, and encourages you to strategize and think about when you plant your items and when they'll be ready for harvest. It's easy to rack up profit via this system, even if you only get to sell once a week.
Unfortunately, at the core of it, the game is still the same. There is not much to it besides farming, theres no mining and fishing is less accessible during winter, so that season often drags on uselessly. The NPCs are bland and say the same thing every day, (so far) regardless of your heart level. Gaining heart levels is excruciatingly slow as well, and you will need a few years minimum to get married due to these harsher requirements.
I'm not sure if you can have a child in this game, as I've not yet played long enough to be able to marry anyone. After getting every upgrade, filling all my fields, and watering, fertilizing, harvesting... a thousand times over, it gets bland. After a year, pretty much everything that can be introduced in the game has been introduced, you've experienced all the festivals, and you've heard all the NPCs have to say.
Part of me wants to keep playing just for the sake of completion, but overall? this game is really boring once you've tried everything once, and that doesn't take long to do. If you're looking for a quick fix of farming, this game might be for you, but its not going to keep you hooked for more than a few days- a week at most. There isn't even any end goal to the storyline to keep you going.
posted by GameGirrl3 (FAIRMONT, WV) Oct 30, 2010
Member since Nov 2006
addition.For me,the biggest "problem" I had with the other DS versions
was that after awhile,the game would get repetitive and I would quit playing and trade the game in.But with this one,the bazaar makes it alot
more exciting for me....I like the fact that you start out with a kitchen,a
barn,and an outside pen for your chickens.And when you buy a dish at
Joan's restaurant or at the bazaar,you automatically learn the recipe.
And I love the windmills too....you can take stuff like milk,eggs,crops,
ores,ect. and make things that can sell for more at the bazaar than the item itself.This probably would be considered a "newbie" game,but I don't think that's a bad thing.I think it's a good starter game for someone who's never played a HM game.So maybe rent it first to see if
you'll like it enough to buy it.