I'm admittedly not a giant fan of soccer but enjoy playing the games from time to time, I thought I'd give this one a whirl. Being the first sports game I'd played on Xbox One I wasn't expecting much (EA's past efforts for "first" games like Madden 06 weren't great).
I can't say I disliked Fifa 14, but can't say I enjoyed it much either. It's a soccer game. It doesn't feel any different than any other soccer game I've played, but I don't play each year so I don't know the changes they may have made. The graphics aren't spectacular - I'd expect this kind of stuff on Xbox 360. If soccer is your thing and you have an Xbox One, this is probably a good game for you but pass otherwise.
Game installed and so did a patch, but it wouldn't make it past the second Barca loading screen, it just dumped back to the home screen. Don't get how it works for some people and not for others. Very disappointed, but glad I didn't buy this game, that's what GameFly is for.