Rent Eternal Sonata for Xbox 360
view large frontback

Eternal Sonata

Rent

Start for as low as $5.95

Also on:PS3
GF Rating
7.2

6242 ratings

Critic & User Reviews

GF Rating
3

Bad

Disappointing

posted by freakazoid_13 (SAN FRANCISCO, CA) May 11, 2012

Member since May 2012

Like a lot of people, I read some fantastic things about Eternal Sonata. I mean, how bad can a game be that's about Frederic Chopin? Unfortunately, the game was frustrating and disappointing.

Not being a fan of turn-based combat, I thought I'd give this game a try because of its real time combat and engaging story. The combat was instead only a mild step up from turn-based, as you can run around on your turn or consume a potion before your turn runs out, and when it's not your turn you can sometimes try and block in coming attacks. But you'll still find yourself tapping X and Y for five minutes with identical results. Gear and weapons don't change your appearance or even change animations during combat, so it makes improving gear and weapons almost pointless. As a result of the repetitive combat system, I gets very old very quickly. And yes, they're not random encounters because you can see them coming, but you're still transported to a "fight scene" and most of the time you can't avoid them.

Yes, the game is very pretty, but it's completely destroyed by the fixed camera perspective that doesn't let you appreciate it or your character's attractiveness. The fixed camera is probably one of my major complaints about the game. It's so far away from the character that I found myself squinting most of the time to try to make out where I was going. The lack of a map didn't help either. I got lost in th woods countless times.

All that aside, I was looking forward to the story line, which sounded genuinely unique and interesting. It was, however, poorly executed and hardly if at all driven by player actions or combat. On top of just flat out ghastly voice acting and cliche, poorly written dialogue, over the course of gratuitously frequent and long cut-scenes make this game virtually un-playable.

If you like poorly executed animes about potentially good ideas and don't mind monotonous combat, maybe you can stomach this unfortunate title. I couldn't.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse

GF Rating
5

Fair

Eternal Sonata

posted by NicheGamer (EL PASO, TX) Apr 16, 2012

Member since Apr 2012

This was one of my favorite games, one of the best rpgs I had ever played. It had orginal combat, a great story, and realistic characters. I wwas enjoying it until I got closer to the end. The closer you get, the more farfetched the story seems. It seems like it will lead up to a great ending that combines everything that has happened. It didn't. I won't reveal anything for those that want to experience this great game, but it was one of the most anticlimatic endings I have ever experienced. It actually ruined this game for me. I still have it, but I haven't played it since I beat it. So if you want to play Eternal Sonata based on its great combat, go ahead. But beware of the stories end.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse

GF Rating
2

Really Bad

I got served by the dancing rat

posted by ExiledNightmare (HALLANDALE BEACH, FL) Apr 6, 2012

Member since Mar 2012

Pretty bad voice acting. Tried using the japanese voice so I would at least not understand what they were saying but when your only useful attack has a catch phrase attatched to it it gets pretty annoying. Got to the part in the sewers with the dancing rat and just couldn't get into it. Didn't dig the character design either. After entering the town of retardo everyone looked like they were gathering fluid in the brain. They had clothing that looked like it was starched solid and their arms had lost blood flow. It looked like it had potential but it just takes too long to get to an interesting part. Played for about an hour or so and all I got to do was walk in big clown feet and slap around some pumpkins and rats. Kind of like kingdom hearts clown feet except that you can't look past them. The scenery was pretty nice and the combat system was a cool turn on turn based but thats about it.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse