The game has some sick parts. I enjoyed the tactical aspects. However I found the Scarecrow levels to be boring and repetitive. Some of the boss fights just go on and on. Some of the Riddler Puzzles are entertaining others are just kind of random. I felt like there wasn't enough fighting overall. Lastly I found it irritating that if you fail at a task once they tell you the "secret". Turns down the sense of accomplishment that should come from strategizing. All in all good but not great.
I think this game was fantastic! I have kind of a crush on Batman and it was so much fun using all his gadgets etc to beat up bad guys. It was a non stop action packed game, and I think the story line was great, especially the parts where you have to fight Scarecrow. I can't wait to play Arkham City next!