The disk was very clean. but the game would not work. My brand new Wii U, that reads any game I put in it, would not read this one and when it did, it would stop working every 15 minutes, even after the update. Now the game play, it looks better than any other assassin's creed, but feels the same. With this in mind, the game seemed very repetitive and with what I was able to play I put the game back in its case and sent it right back!