Rent Alone in the Dark for PS2
view large frontback

Alone in the Dark


Start your 1-month FREE Trial!

Also on:Wii, Xbox 360, PS3
GF Rating

464 ratings

Critic & User Reviews

GF Rating

Really Bad

What could have been...

posted by Amonoi (Columbus, GA) Jul 8, 2008

Member since Jun 2008

Every serial gamer has the memory of a game that could have been great. Every obsessive gamer has a hall of fame of games that could have rocked - this game is going into mine post-haste.

I heard such good things about it; previews that tantalized and titillated. Seeing the game in my mailbox had me bouncing with joy. Then I popped it in and was fascinated... for all of five minutes.

Graphics are poor even for a last gen, no especially for a last gen console. Sound quality is skewed across the board. Some things are cinema loud, while others barely register. The controls which make an effort to be intuitive are instead frustrating enough to make you quit off the bat.

Then of course there's the "M. Night" what a twist plot... Put it this way - if you've seen any Night movie since the Sixth Sense, especially if it's the sadness that is "The Happening" walk away now. The story is no reason what so ever to play this game.

In short, this game which had features like real time and space inventory; beautiful cut scenes; and the ability to improvise items worthy of McGaiver's genius should have been an instant classic. Instead it's a combination of heartsick and headache that I wish I could have skipped.

If you've already ordered this game - leave it in the envelope and mail it back.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse

GF Rating


Why Atari, why?

posted by BLorend (PARADISE, CA) Jul 6, 2008

Member since Mar 2007

Let me say for one that Alone in the Dark: The New Nightmare was/is one of my favorite survival/horror games of all time back on the PSOne. So when I heard Alone in the Dark was coming to PS2/PS3 and so on, I was pretty stoked. It's with great pity then that I must say, this game is not worth it.

First off, an ending of a game can make or break it, see Myst which has one of the worst almost-endings of all time. This one now has my number two spot. It makes you feel like there's more, a lot more to the story, which is pretty weak to begin with. Why Atari did you spend days on the mechanics only to screw with us so on the endings?

Second off, I got this game to play a survival horror game, or at least an action game, the two driving sequences in the game are a major pain in the butt, not to mention very poorly viewed with the cameras.

Why Atari, why did you have to come so far to drop it? What were you thinking with this almost ending? That you want to leave us wanting more? Then at least leave an ending with some kind of conclusion! Is there more game on the other versions? I don't know, but if it is, very poor planning on Atari's part yet again. I so wanted this game to be good, but really, I just can't say that, and I'm pretty tolerant of most things.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse

GF Rating


Original and good potential, but many problems.

posted by Nestly (MADISON, WI) Jul 2, 2008

Member since Jun 2008

Alone in the Dark was, I admit, an entertaining game to play. I liked its originality and different style. It made things tough to figure out, and as many times as I got stuck in that game, it felt more rewarding when I figured it out. The hints were very vague, but there nonetheless. You just have to really look.

The obstacles mostly consist of puzzles, and enemy fights are mostly optional. (You can usually run right past them and take less damage.) There's not much variety in enemies, but again, it's mostly based on investigation, not fights. No boss battles and such. It's mostly consisted of realism.

Problems? The game just could've been developed more. It's as if they just rushed to finish it. Characters move in a blocky form, and the game is generally very short. I was having fun until the ending, which made no sense and was extremely unfulfilling.
"...What? THAT'S the end?"
Although putting the entire game in a DVD movie sort of fashion was creative and interesting. As if you were playing through a movie.

The perks for me were one, the music. Nicely composed, ambient feeling that went well with the game. Also, the realistic healing and inventory system. Lastly, the challenge of figuring out a situation. It was about the only thing that prevented me from finishing the game in a few hours.

All in all, if you'd like a quick game to be entertained by and play through, it's a nice, interesting rent. But definitely far from being perfect, and definitely not a buyer.

Was this review helpful? Report Abuse